A landlord asking for pay stubs and ID is normal. Handing over every number printed on those documents is not required, and in most cases the person reviewing your application doesn’t want it either. They’re trying to answer two narrow questions: are you who you say you are, and do you earn enough to pay the rent. Everything on the page that doesn’t help answer those questions is, from your side, just exposure.
Here’s what a reviewer looks for on each document, what you can usually cover, and how to do it without making the page look tampered with. Landlord screening rules differ between cities, states and provinces, and some places restrict what a landlord can ask for or keep. If you have a specific concern about what’s being requested, a local tenant organization or housing office can tell you what applies where you live.
What a landlord is reading on a pay stub
A pay stub carries more than it needs to. A typical one shows your name and address, your employer, the pay period and pay date, gross pay, deductions, net pay, year-to-date totals, sometimes an employee number, often part of a tax ID, and on some stubs the bank account the deposit went into.
For a rental decision, the useful parts are:
- Your name, so it matches the application
- Your employer’s name, which they may use to verify employment
- The pay period and pay date, to confirm the stub is recent
- Gross pay and year-to-date earnings, to estimate annual income
That’s the core. Net pay is sometimes looked at too, so leave it visible. Deductions are rarely relevant, though covering them can look odd and isn’t worth the effort.
What you can usually cover without raising eyebrows:
- Bank account and routing numbers (these have no role in a rental decision)
- Employee ID numbers
- All but the last few digits of any tax or social insurance number
- Health plan or benefit election details, if they’re itemized
The rule that matters more than any of these: never cover, alter or “tidy” the income figures. A landlord who suspects a doctored pay stub will usually move on, and in some places submitting falsified documents on an application can have consequences well beyond losing the apartment.
What a landlord is reading on your ID
Identity documents are simpler. The reviewer wants your full legal name, a photo that matches the person they’ll meet, and often your date of birth for screening. The front of a driver’s license or state or provincial ID covers this. Passport photo pages work too.
The back of a license usually adds a barcode and sometimes restrictions or endorsements. Unless the landlord asks for it, leave it out.
Some people cover the ID number itself. Whether that’s acceptable depends on how the landlord runs screening; some use it, many don’t. This is a fair thing to ask about directly: “For the ID, do you need the license number visible, or just name, photo and date of birth?”
How to cover details so it doesn’t look like tampering
There’s a difference between a clean redaction and a page that looks edited. A neat solid bar over an account number reads as careful. A smudge, a crop that cuts off half the stub, or a box that clips the edge of an income figure reads as something to question.
Two reliable approaches:
Cover before you scan. Lay a strip of opaque paper or a sticky note over the details on the original, then scan. This is low-tech and the result is unambiguous: the information was never captured.
Mark up the scanned page. If you’re working from a PDF your employer emailed you, or you’ve already scanned the page, you can draw a solid box over the detail. In FaxLane, the markup tools let you draw on a page before it’s sent, so you can cover an account number and then check the result in the preview. Covering the paper before you scan is still the safer method, because the information is never captured at all. If you do mark up a page, zoom in on the preview and confirm the detail is fully hidden before you send.
A caution about PDFs you plan to email or upload elsewhere: drawing a black box on a PDF in some apps only adds a layer on top, and the original text can still be selected or copied underneath. Covering the paper before you scan avoids the problem entirely, which matters most if you reuse the same file for an online portal.
Send recent, readable copies
Most landlords want the two or three most recent stubs. Older ones don’t help your case and just add pages. If your pay is irregular (hourly with variable shifts, commission, tips), a longer run or a year-to-date figure can tell a clearer story than one unusually low or high week; a short note on the cover page explaining that context is reasonable.
For readability, keep in mind that fax is black and white. Light gray text, colored backgrounds and tiny numbers in a pay stub’s footer are the first things to wash out. Scan in even light, keep the page flat, and zoom in on the preview before sending to make sure the gross pay and dates are crisp. If the digital PDF from your payroll portal is available, use that rather than photographing a printout; it will almost always come through cleaner.
When income isn’t a standard pay stub
Plenty of applicants don’t have neat biweekly stubs. Some common alternatives, all subject to what the landlord will accept:
- New job: an offer letter on company letterhead with salary and start date
- Self-employed: recent bank statements showing deposits, invoices, or a tax return summary
- Benefits or pension income: an award or benefit statement
- Student: proof of financial aid, a guarantor’s documents, or both
Bank statements are where oversharing gets easy. A landlord might want to see deposits and a balance, but they don’t need your full account number, and they usually don’t need every individual purchase. Ask whether a statement with the account number partly covered is acceptable, and whether they need full transaction detail or just the summary page.
Before you hit send
Confirm the fax number directly with the landlord or property manager, not from a forwarded message or a search result. Then ask one practical question: is the fax machine in a private area, or a shared one at a front desk? If it’s shared, a cover page marked with the property manager’s name and “Confidential: rental application” at least keeps it from being casually read by whoever walks by.
Put the pages in a sensible order (application, ID, then income documents, most recent first) and review the whole packet. FaxLane asks you to confirm the recipient number before sending, which is a good moment to slow down, because once a fax is delivered it can’t be recalled. Keep the delivery receipt; it records when the landlord’s machine accepted the pages.
A note on what happens to your documents
It’s reasonable to ask a landlord how they store application documents and how long they keep them, especially if you aren’t offered the unit. Some jurisdictions have rules about this; many landlords simply have a habit. You won’t always get a detailed answer, but asking signals that you take it seriously, and a property manager who bristles at the question has told you something useful.
If the place falls through and you have real concerns about how your information was handled, a local tenant rights group or consumer protection office is the right place to ask what, if anything, applies.
Quick answers
Can I black out information on my pay stub before sending it to a landlord?
Many landlords accept pay stubs with certain details covered, such as bank account numbers, employee ID numbers or most of a tax ID number, as long as your name, employer, pay period and income figures are still readable. Never cover or change the income amounts. If you're unsure, ask the landlord what they need to see before you send.
Do I need to send both sides of my driver's license to a landlord?
Usually not. The front shows your name, photo and date of birth, which is what most landlords use to confirm identity. Send the back only if they specifically ask for it.
Is it safe to fax pay stubs and ID?
Only as safe as the care you take. Confirm the number with the landlord, ask whether the fax machine is in a private office, and send only the pages and details they need. Once a fax is delivered, you can't take it back.